PI's submission to the UK government's Make Work Pay consultation

Our submission to the UK government on the use of workplace monitoring technologies to track, score and and make decisions about employees.

Advocacy
Photo by Andres Siimon on Unsplash

Photo by Andres Siimon on Unsplash

At PI we have been observing with concern the growing use of workplace monitoring technologies (WMT), which allow employers to track, score and make decisions about workers in ways that are often opaque, intrusive and difficult to challenge. 

We responded to the Department for Business, Innovation, Science and Trade's consultation on the fair, transparent and responsible use of WMT, which was launched in line with the commitments in the Plan to Make Work Pay. While the government's eight proposed principles could make a positive contribution, we argued that they leave important elements of good practice unaddressed, and that WMT are inherently intrusive and coercive enough that specific rules may be needed on top of existing data protection law. 

In our submission, drawing on our research into AI recruitment platforms, work-from-home monitoring software, the gig economy and the creator economy, we recommended that the government:

  • Strengthen data protection foundations: Articulate data minimisation and purpose limitation as standalone principles, requiring employers to demonstrate they collect only the minimum data necessary for a specific aim, and prohibiting worker data from being repurposed, sold or shared with third parties beyond its original stated purpose, including following a company's bankruptcy or closure.
  • Look beyond anonymisation: Recognise that anonymous or aggregated data does not eliminate the risk of re-identification, and can still be used in ways that leverage employer power and information asymmetries to workers' disadvantage.
  • Guarantee transparency and explainability in automated decision-making: Require clear and accessible explanations of how algorithms work, the relative importance of their inputs and parameters, whether decisions are advisory or decisive, and personalised explanations of individual decisions, without which the promised appeal route is ineffective.
  • Enable independent scrutiny: Ensure workers, their representatives and public interest groups can test how algorithms work, through sandboxes, API access or source code sharing, with support to access the technical expertise needed to engage.
  • Introduce anti-retaliation protections: Protect workers from adverse treatment for questioning or challenging decisions or raising concerns, since a right to challenge that carries the risk of retaliation is not one workers can use safely.
  • Ensure meaningful worker engagement: Require employers to consult workers about whether monitoring is necessary at all before proposals are developed, to involve workers in impact assessments conducted before deployment is finalised, and to consult and negotiate with trade unions or employee representatives before WMT is introduced.