Austria proposes to seize asylum seekers' devices to check their identities and travel routes

In April 2018, the Austrian cabinet agreed on legislation that required asylum seekers would be forced to hand over their mobile devices to allow authorities to check their identities and origins. If they have been found to have entered another EU country first, under the Dublin regulation, they can be sent back there. The number of asylum seekers has dropped substantially since 2016, when measures were taken to close the Balkan route. The bill, which must pass Parliament, also allows the authorities to seize up to €840 to pay for the migrants' upkeep while waiting for their claims to be processed; requires hospitals to disclose when they will be discharged, to facilitate deportations; and will raise the length of time refugees must wait to apply for Austrian citizenship to ten years.

Writer: Bethany Bell
Publication: BBC


What is Privacy International calling for?

Data should be protected

Data should be protected from access by persons who are not the user.

Security for all

There should be no barriers to timely fixes in security -- including updates, patches, and workarounds -- particularly considering implications for users of various socio-economic status and citizenship. Security updates should be distinguishable from feature updates.

Limit data analysis by design

As nearly every human interaction now generates some form of data, systems should be designed to limit the invasiveness of data analysis by all parties in the transaction and networking.

Control over intelligence

Individuals should have control over the data generated about their activities, conduct, devices, and interactions, and be able to determine who is gaining this intelligence and how it is to be used.

Identities under our control

Individuals must be able to selectively disclose their identity, generate new identities, pseudonyms, and/or remain anonymous.