Win! Tribunal orders UK Government to come clean about secret order to Apple

UK Government is required to acknowledge whether they have issued any secret orders to Apple undermine cloud security.

Achieved Result

The UK Government’s can no longer shield from scrutiny an issue of immense public interest - whether it ordered Apple to undermine the security of our devices and data - based on an unsupported claim of a risk to national security. 

News & Analysis

Today, the UK Investigatory Powers Tribunal has ordered the UK Government to come clean about giving a secret order to Apple, reportedly in order to weaken Apple’s encrypted services. This is a big win for accountability, transparency and online security.

The ruling requires the UK Government to acknowledge whether they have in fact issued any ‘Technical Capability Notices’ (TCNs) to Apple. Even though this has been widely reported on over the past two years, up until this ruling the UK Government maintained a position of neither confirming nor denying the existence of any TCN. This was despite reported confirmation from unnamed government sources and the notices being openly discussed by US President Trump and his former Director of National Intelligence.

The judgment hinges in part on the Government’s inconsistent assertion of its neither confirm nor deny (NCND) policy. The Tribunal concludes that the Government’s departures from that policy, including by admitting the existence of the TCN to reporters and the US Government, undermines its reliance on it now. The Government also failed to provide detailed evidence as to why revealing that Apple had received a TCN would undermine national security.

This judgment comes out of a legal case brought by PI, Liberty and two individuals challenging the lawfulness - and the secrecy - of the TCN regime. The matter is being case managed with a second claim brought by Apple which also addresses the now-confirmed TCN.

Caroline Wilson Palow, Legal Director at Privacy International, said:

"Today’s judgment is a major victory for transparency and effective oversight. The Investigatory Powers Tribunal has rightly rejected the UK Government’s attempts to shield from scrutiny an issue of immense public interest - whether Apple has been ordered to undermine the security of our devices - based on an unsupported claim of a risk to national security. The Government should not be allowed to use its policy of ‘neither confirm nor deny’ as an impenetrable shield.

This is the second time this year that the Government has been embarrassed by an inconsistent and unjustified claim of NCND. The Government can’t have its cake and eat it too by claiming secrecy in legal challenges but eschewing it when revelations serve political ends.

While today we learned Apple has indeed been served with a technical capability notice, there are many more questions to answer, including whether a secret regime of this sort should even exist in a democratic society. If a government wants to ban a technology or a form of digital security, it should be upfront about that. That transparency is crucial to democratic accountability."

Notes for editors

  • Privacy International, Liberty and two individuals are challenging the UK Government’s Technical Capability Notices (TCNs) regime which allows the Government to issue secret orders to companies for national security purposes, but which may also be used to undermine privacy and security features.
  • Our challenge disputes the secrecy, lawfulness, and necessity of TCNs as enshrined in the Investigatory Powers Act 2016 (IPA). The case is being heard by the Investigatory Powers Tribunal (IPT), a specialist body which hears challenges against the investigatory powers and the intelligence agencies.
  • Apple also has a case pending before the IPT challenging the TCN regime. The IPT has held hearings to assess how the two claims should be managed together. Today’s result comes out of the latest of those hearings, at which the question of whether the Government can reasonably maintain its policy of neither confirm nor deny (NCND) as to the notices served to Apple was raised.
  • The government’s policy of neither confirming nor denying certain information on national security grounds also came under scrutiny recently in the case of Agent X, in which “MI5 gave false evidence to three courts about having kept to its core secrecy policy - known as ‘neither confirm nor deny’ (NCND) - about the agent status of the violent neo-Nazi informant.”
  • Under the IPA, the UK Government can issue TCNs which, among other things, can be used to require a company to remove encryption on its services. A company that receives a TCN is legally barred from commenting on it publicly.
  • It was widely reported in February 2025 that Apple received a notice requiring it to provide access to data stored on iCloud which was being protected by an advanced for of encryption Apple call Advanced Data Protection (ADP).
  • In April 2025, the Investigatory Powers Tribunal acknowledged it would hear a claim from Apple regarding the TCN regime. The UK Government had tried to block even that basic level of transparency.
  • In September 2025, the UK reportedly withdrew a TCN to Apple under pressure from the US Government.
  • In October 2025, the Financial Times reported that Apple was subject to a second notice which is understood to seek to restrict its scope to the UK. Although we maintain the impact is still global in character.
  • Shortly thereafter, Apple’s first challenge before the Investigatory Powers Tribunal was dismissed due to a “change in circumstances”.
  • Apple’s current challenge to the now-confirmed TCN was filed in July 2026.
  • The UK’s TCN regime is globally unusual in terms of its scope of powers and lack of transparency. A recent global review of threats to encryption found the UK’s restrictions to be ‘severe’ - the highest rating. Colombia was the only other OECD country to receive a rating of ‘severe’.
  • International institutions and courts have repeatedly emphasised the foundational role that encryption plays in realising human rights - in particular for those at risk of government oppression.
  • Recent polling has shown that only 12% of the UK public believe the government should be able to secretly order technology companies to provide access to their users’ information, and prohibit technology companies from notifying the public when they receive such orders and that across the EU, 77% consider encryption important for protecting their private online communications.